How do Body-worn Cameras Affect the Amount and Makeup of Police-initiated Activities? A Randomized Controlled Trial in Milwaukee, Wisconsin

• NCJ Number: 309577
• Journal: Journal of Experimental Criminology Volume: 16 Dated: December 2019 Pages: 481-503
• Author(s): Daniel S. Lawrence; Bryce E. Peterson
• Date Published: December 2019
• Length: 23 pages
• Grant Number(s): 2015-WY-BX-0006
• Agencies: BJA-Sponsored
• Publication Type: Research (Applied/Empirical)
• Award: Milwaukee Police Department Body Cameras evaluation Project

Annotation

This document reports on the research methodology and outcomes of a randomized controlled trial to determine how the amount and nature of police-initiated activities changed after body-worn cameras were introduced to the Milwaukee Police Department.

Abstract

This paper reports on an examination of how the amount and makeup of police-initiated activities changed after the introduction of body-worn cameras (BWCs). From May 21 to November 22, 2016, patrol officers and sergeants from the Milwaukee Police Department were involved in a randomized controlled trial. Through a stratified random sampling procedure, half the officers (n = 252) were assigned BWCs, while officers from the control group (n = 252) continued business as usual. The counts of proactive activities, which included a total count of self-initiated events, as well as traffic stops, business checks, subject stops, and park and walks, were examined using random-effects negative binominal panel regression analyses. The models included a unique measure of contamination to assess its impact on officers’ proactivity. BWCs had no impact on the total amount of officer-initiated activities, traffic stops, or business checks. Officers with BWCs conducted approximately 8% fewer subject stops and 23% more park and walks than those in the control group. In all models, contamination levels were significantly, positively associated with the number of proactive activities that were conducted; however, the size of this effect was very small. Results suggest that BWC-wearing officers may be less likely to engage in proactive activities that are highly discretionary and that could potentially lead to confrontations with community members. As departments continue to develop BWC programs or fine-tune their existing BWC policies, more research is needed to understand the degree to which BWCs affect officers’ behaviors and interactions with the public. (Published Abstract Provided)